Huggies vs Up Up: A Comparison of Diaper Brands

Published:

Updated:

Author:

Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

If you’re a parent, you know that diapers are one of the biggest expenses in the first few years of your baby’s life. With so many options available, it can be hard to decide which brand to choose. In this article, we’ll take an in-depth look at the differences between Huggies and Target Up & Up diapers to help you make an informed decision.

We’ll cover everything from size and absorbency testing to overnight performance and cost comparisons. Plus, we’ll analyze the manufacturing location, ingredients, comfort, fit, and look of both brands. By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of which brand is the better choice for your baby.

Key Takeaways

  • This article provides an in-depth analysis of Huggies and Target Up & Up diapers, including absorbency testing, size, cost, and more.
  • The article compares the manufacturing location and ingredients of both brands, as well as the comfort, fit, and look of the diapers.
  • By the end of the article, you’ll be able to make an informed decision about which brand is the best choice for your baby.

Size

When it comes to diaper sizing, Huggies Little Snugglers and Target Up & Up diapers are very similar in size. However, there are some slight differences in measurements. For example, Huggies diapers are slightly smaller in some measurements, while Target diapers have a larger waistband. Nevertheless, the Huggies diaper has good stretch on the waistband, making it a comfortable fit for babies.

In terms of sizing options, Huggies Little Snugglers diapers are available in newborn size (up to 10 lb.) to size 4 (22-37 lb.). After size 4, Huggies switches over to their Little Movers line which are available up to size 7 (above 41 lb.). Target Up & Up diapers are available from newborn (up to 10 lb.) to size 7 (above 41 lb.).

It’s worth noting that Huggies offers preemie size diapers, while Up & Up does not. This is an advantage for Huggies, especially for parents who have premature babies. However, it’s understandable why Target may not offer preemie size diapers since they may not have a large enough market for it.

To give you an idea of the specific measurements, here is a table comparing the measurements of Huggies Little Snugglers and Target Up & Up diapers:

Huggies Snugglers Target Up & Up
Height 7″ 7″
Width 4.5″ 4″
Between Legs 3.25″ 3″
Front waistband 9″ 9.5″
Velcro Strip 7.75″ 5.4″
Back waistband 9″ 10.5″
Back waistband stretched 12.5″ 12.5″

Overall, both Huggies and Target Up & Up diapers are great options for parents. They offer a wide range of sizes to fit babies of different weights, and their sizes are very similar.

Absorbency Testing

Target Up & Up Diaper Absorbency Testing

If you’re looking for a store brand diaper that can hold up against name-brand diapers, Target’s Up & Up diapers are a solid choice. During absorbency testing, they performed well, especially at lower volumes.

After each pour of 50 mL of colored water, the Up & Up diaper quickly absorbed the liquid. There was a bit of dampness on the paper towel touch test, but overall, the diaper did a decent job of absorbing the majority of the liquid efficiently.

Up & Up’s performance held strong until the 300 mL pour, after which point the paper towel touch test was wetter. It lagged behind Huggies at the highest volumes. However, after the ~10-minute final resting period, the final paper towel touch test was totally dry. When touched with skin, the Up & Up diaper actually felt the driest of all the diapers tested in this trial run.

Huggies Swaddlers Absorbency Testing

Huggies Little Snugglers outperformed all other diapers tested in this trial run for absorbency efficiency at the initial pours. During testing, Huggies rocked the first half of the absorption tests and had very solid performance at the higher volumes too.

After each pour of 50 mL of colored water, Huggies quickly absorbed the liquid and the paper towel test came away completely dry after the 50 mL and 100 mL pours and was only ever-so-slightly damp at 150 mL.

By the 200 mL pour, the paper towel test started to show some wetness. However, Huggies Little Snugglers still did a great job at absorbing the large volumes and decidedly beat out the Up & Up diapers at the final pours.

After the final resting period, Huggies did well on the paper towel test but felt just slightly damper than the Target Up & Up, though the difference wasn’t significant.

Overall, Huggies owned the absorbency test vs. the Target Up & Up’s.

Diaper Brand Absorbency Test Results
Target Up & Up Decent job of absorbing the majority of the liquid efficiently. Held strong until the 300 mL pour. Felt the driest of all the diapers tested.
Huggies Little Snugglers Rocked the first half of the absorption tests. Solid performance at higher volumes. Beat out the Up & Up diapers at the final pours. Outperformed all other diapers tested.

In conclusion, if absorbency is a top priority for you, Huggies Little Snugglers are the way to go. However, if you’re looking for a more affordable option that still performs well, Target’s Up & Up diapers are a good choice.

Overnight Performance of Huggies vs. Up & Up

When it comes to overnight performance, both Huggies and Up & Up diapers have proven to be reliable options for parents. Up & Up diapers have minimal leaking incidents, and babies’ skin is never irritated from dampness. Huggies diapers also have few leak incidents, with only a slight dampness on the outer shell of the diaper. Both brands have proven to be trustworthy for overnight use, making it a tie between the two.

To ensure a good night’s sleep, it’s essential to use a diaper that can keep up with your baby’s needs. While both Up & Up and Huggies diapers have proven to be reliable for overnight use, it’s important to note that every baby is different. It’s recommended to try both brands and see which one works best for your baby’s needs.

Cost Comparison: Target Up & Up vs. Huggies Diapers

When it comes to buying diapers, cost is a major factor to consider. Target’s Up & Up diapers are a store brand that offers a cost savings compared to name brand Huggies. As of Oct. 2022, a big box of Huggies size 2 diapers costs about $0.29 per diaper, while Target’s Up & Up diapers cost about half that at $0.14 per diaper. This significant cost difference could cut your diapering costs in half compared to name brand Huggies.

Although you can save a little on Huggies by buying them at Costco, which drops the price to $0.23 per diaper for Little Snugglers, the cost is still significantly higher than Up & Up diapers. However, once you switch to Little Movers, Costco prices for Huggies are about the same as other stores.

While Huggies are stocked at most retailers, you have to buy Up & Up diapers at Target. Fortunately, a big box of diapers is just shy of Target’s $35 free shipping minimum, so this isn’t likely to be a big inconvenience.

In conclusion, if you’re looking to save money on diapers, Up & Up diapers are a great option. They offer a cost savings compared to name brand Huggies, and while you have to buy them at Target, this is a small inconvenience for the significant savings.

Manufacturing Location

Both Huggies and Target Up & Up diapers are manufactured in the United States.

Ingredients of Up & Up vs. Huggies Diapers

When it comes to the ingredients in Up & Up vs. Huggies diapers, Huggies stands out for its detailed ingredient list. Both brands are fragrance-free, latex-free, and chlorine-free, but Huggies goes the extra mile to explain each ingredient used in their diapers.

Huggies Little Snugglers diapers contain wood pulp, polypropylene, polyethylene, polyurethane elastics, polyolefin elastic, adhesives, colorants, printing ink, sodium polyacrylate (absorbent material), polyester, and a color-changing wetness indicator.

On the other hand, Up & Up diapers only list polyester, polypropylene, and polyethylene as their ingredients. While they claim to be hypoallergenic and lotion-free, they do not provide any further information about their materials.

It’s worth noting that chlorine is a concern due to its environmental impact and possible exposure to dioxins. While both brands are elemental-chlorine free, Huggies specifies that no direct chlorine was used in their manufacturing process.

Overall, Huggies offers more transparency and information about their ingredients, which can be helpful for parents concerned about diaper rash, skin irritation, and overall skin health.

Comfort of Huggies vs. Up & Up’s

When it comes to diaper softness, Huggies Little Snugglers are the clear winner. Their diapers are very soft compared to Up & Up’s which feel more smooth and slightly plastic-y. Huggies achieved a high level of softness with the inner leg gusset elastic, which is both light around the skin and functional for blowout prevention. Target Up & Up diapers are thinner than Huggies Little Snugglers when dry, but both diapers bulk up considerably with the introduction of liquid. However, now that your baby walks, the filling in Up & Up shifts and bunches up a lot, which can lead to leaks. Both Huggies and Up & Up diapers have umbilical cord space in their newborn sizes.

Overall, the winner for comfort is Huggies. Their Little Snugglers are much softer than Target diapers, making them a great choice for parents who prioritize the comfort of their baby’s skin.

Fit & Secureness of Huggies and Up & Up

When it comes to fit and secureness, Huggies Little Snugglers and Target Up & Up diapers are very similar. Both diapers provide a secure fit, but the actual fit will depend on your baby’s proportions. For example, some parents prefer Up & Up diapers for their second baby more than their first baby because of their size.

The waistband of Huggies Little Snugglers includes a thoughtful detail of a back pocket, which is not included in Target Up & Up’s waistband. This back pocket is added to help reduce the risk of poop blowouts, which is especially useful for younger babies who tend to have more watery poop. On the other hand, Huggies Little Movers have a snugger back elastic instead of pockets.

Both Huggies and Up & Up tabs have appropriate stretch to get a good fit. However, the Huggies tabs have a little more stretch than the Up & Up tabs.

Huggies includes something they call “grip strips” on their diapers’ waistband where the tabs connect. These purple strips are designed to make the fasten of the tabs even tighter. However, some parents have found these grip strips to be more of a negative than a positive. If your baby moves a lot, you may need to readjust the tabs as you diaper them. Pulling the tabs off and on the grip strips a few times may wear the fabric of the diaper some. Additionally, the grip strips may grab onto other pieces of the diaper, which can be annoying when you are trying to hold down your baby with one hand and open the diaper with the other.

It is worth noting that now that some babies are walking, some parents have been disappointed with the sturdiness of Target Up & Up diapers. There have been a couple of occasions where the diaper has fallen off.

Overall, Huggies wins in this category with the added premium features, though some parents could do without the grip strips.

Look of Huggies vs. Up & Up Diapers

When it comes to the look of diapers, there are a few features to consider. Both Huggies Little Snugglers and Target Up & Up diapers include wetness indicators, which can be a useful tool for parents to know when it’s time for a diaper change. However, Huggies seems to have the advantage with size indicators, as some of their diapers include images where the tab fastens for this purpose. As the image is revealed as the baby’s waist gets bigger, it is time to size up. On the other hand, there are little circles on the Little Snugglers, but nowhere is it made explicit that these are in fact size indicators, making it too easy for someone to miss.

When it comes to design, Huggies diapers have more of a design than Target Up & Up’s. All the Huggies diapers have been Disney themed, and the ones tested here had Winnie the Pooh characters on them. This is an added bonus for parents who want to add a little bit of fun to their diaper changing routine. Target Up & Up diapers have two designs in the package, one with a pattern on the outer sell and one with only white and a pattern on the waistband.

Overall, it’s a tie between Huggies and Target Up & Up diapers in terms of look. While Huggies has an advantage with the size indicators, they don’t advertise this feature well, making it too easy to overlook. However, Huggies has the added bonus of fun Disney designs, while Target Up & Up has a more simplistic design. Ultimately, the choice between the two may come down to personal preference.

Conclusion: Huggies or Up & Up Diapers

When comparing Huggies and Target Up & Up diapers, it ultimately comes down to your specific needs and priorities. Both brands have their strengths and weaknesses, and understanding these can help you make an informed decision.

Huggies Diapers

  • Huggies outperforms Up & Up diapers in various aspects, particularly in absorbency, ingredients, comfort, fit, and secureness.
  • The diapers are designed to quickly absorb a significant amount of liquid, offering premium features such as softness for comfort and added blowout protection.

Target Up & Up Diapers

  • While not as absorbent as Huggies, Target Up & Up diapers still offer good absorbency, performing well in overnight testing.
  • They are a more budget-friendly option compared to Huggies, providing a balance between functionality and cost-effectiveness.

Ultimately, the decision between Huggies and Up & Up diapers depends on your budget and specific needs. While Huggies may offer superior performance, the cost difference compared to Up & Up diapers may be a significant factor to consider, especially when factoring in the long-term expenses of diapering a baby.

It’s important to note that personal experiences with the diapers may vary, and considering factors such as your baby’s activity level and individual preferences can also influence your decision.

If you’re still undecided, exploring other diaper comparisons, such as Up & Up vs. Mama Bear Diapers, Huggies vs. Pampers Diapers, Mama Bear vs. Pampers Diapers, and BJ’s Berkley Jensen Diaper Review, can provide further insights to help you make the best choice for your baby.

About the author

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir

Latest Posts

  • Middle Names that Start with X: A Guide to Unique Naming Choices

    Middle Names that Start with X: A Guide to Unique Naming Choices

    Choosing a middle name for your newborn can be as pivotal as selecting their first name. Particularly, middle names that start with “X” offer a unique blend of modernity, cultural richness, and a touch of the exotic. This article dives into the world of middle names beginning with X, exploring their meanings, cultural significance, and…

    Read more

  • Unique Middle Names Starting with Y: A Guide for Parents

    Unique Middle Names Starting with Y: A Guide for Parents

    Choosing a middle name for your child is a significant step in shaping their identity. Middle names that start with ‘Y’ offer a unique blend of charm and distinction, setting your child apart. In this guide, we delve into the world of middle names beginning with the letter ‘Y’, exploring their origins, meanings, and the…

    Read more

  • Middle Names That Start With X: A Guide to Unique and Meaningful Choices

    Middle Names That Start With X: A Guide to Unique and Meaningful Choices

    Choosing a middle name for your child is a significant decision, one that can add depth and character to their identity. In recent years, names starting with ‘X’ have gained popularity, offering a blend of uniqueness and cultural richness. This article delves into the world of middle names beginning with ‘X’, providing insights into their…

    Read more