If you’re a new parent, you’re likely wondering which store brand diaper is the best. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one for your baby. In this article, we’ll be taking an in-depth look at two popular store brand diapers: Target’s Up & Up and Wal-Mart’s Parent’s Choice.
What sets this review apart is that we’ve actually used and tested hundreds of diapers on our baby. We’ll be analyzing various factors such as size, fit, absorption, overnight performance, cost, ingredients, and more. Additionally, we’ve conducted experimental tests to compare the absorption of each diaper side by side, which have been photo documented and animated for your convenience. So, if you’re looking for an unbiased and thorough review of Up & Up vs. Parent’s Choice diapers, keep reading.
- We’ve tested hundreds of diapers on our baby to provide an in-depth analysis of Up & Up vs. Parent’s Choice.
- Our review covers various factors such as size, fit, absorption, overnight performance, cost, and ingredients.
- We’ve conducted experimental tests to compare the absorption of each diaper side by side, which have been photo documented and animated for your convenience.
Size of Up & Up’s and Parent’s Choice Diapers
The size of a diaper is an important factor to consider when choosing the right diaper for your baby. In this review, both Parent’s Choice and Target Up & Up diapers were tested in size 2, which is intended for babies between 12-18 lbs. Parent’s Choice size 2 diapers were found to run a bit larger than Target Up & Up’s. The measurements for each diaper are shown in the table below:
|Target Up & Up
|Back waistband stretched
Both Parent’s Choice and Target Up & Up diapers are available from newborn (up to 10 lbs.) to size 7 (above 41 lbs.). It is important to note that personal preference plays a role in determining which size diaper is best for your baby. Some parents prefer diapers that run larger for cost-saving reasons, as the cost per diaper increases as you go up in sizes. Overall, the size of Parent’s Choice and Target Up & Up diapers are comparable, and the choice ultimately depends on personal preference.
Absorption Testing: Wal-Mart vs. Target Diapers
When it comes to choosing the right diaper for your baby, absorption is a crucial factor to consider. To compare the absorbency of Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice and Target Up & Up diapers, both brands underwent an absorption testing process.
Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice Diaper Absorbency Testing
Wal-Mart’s Parent’s Choice diapers did not perform well during the absorbency testing. In fact, it was the worst performer out of over ten different types of diapers tested. The diaper felt wet even after the first 50mL pour and continued to be wet with each subsequent pour. At 300mL, the diaper had not fully absorbed the liquid and was still visibly absorbing at 350mL. Even after a 10-minute rest, the diaper still had dampness on the paper towel test and felt wetter to the touch than other diapers.
These results were consistent with the experience of the diapers on a baby. The Parent’s Choice diaper failed to contain high volume liquids and led to leakage and blowouts.
Target Up & Up Absorbency Testing
Target’s Up & Up diapers, on the other hand, showed a better performance during the absorbency testing. The diaper quickly absorbed all the liquid poured during the testing, even at higher volumes. Although it was not completely dry on the paper towel test, it performed far better than the Parent’s Choice diaper.
The Up & Up diaper absorbed the majority of the liquid on the first pours, and its performance only started to falter a little at 300mL and 350mL. After a 10-minute rest, the diaper had a dry paper towel test and performed better than the Parent’s Choice diaper.
Based on the results of the absorbency testing, the Target Up & Up diaper is the winner. It had a very solid performance, while the Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice diaper failed to absorb all the high volume liquids quickly.
In conclusion, when it comes to choosing between Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice and Target Up & Up diapers, the Up & Up diaper is the better option for parents looking for a more absorbent and reliable diaper.
When it comes to overnight diapers, you want to be sure that your baby stays dry and comfortable throughout the night. Two popular options are Parent’s Choice and Up & Up diapers.
According to a parent who has used both brands, Parent’s Choice diapers were reliable for overnight use with their first baby. However, the daytime performance of the redesigned diapers was poor, causing a lack of trust in using them for an overnight test. On the other hand, Up & Up diapers have worked great for this parent overnight, with very rare leakage and a secure fit even when filled to capacity in the morning.
It is worth noting that as the baby grew older, the Up & Up diapers were no longer suitable for overnight use and caused multiple instances of waking up soaked. This may be a consideration for parents with older babies.
Overall, based on this parent’s experience, Target’s Up & Up diapers are the better choice for overnight use due to their reliable performance and secure fit. However, it is important to keep in mind that every baby is different and may have different needs when it comes to overnight diapers.
- Parent’s Choice diapers were reliable for overnight use with their first baby, but poor daytime performance of the redesigned diapers caused a lack of trust in using them for overnight use.
- Up & Up diapers worked great for overnight use when the baby was smaller, but caused multiple instances of waking up soaked as the baby grew older.
- Target’s Up & Up diapers are the better choice for overnight use based on this parent’s experience, but every baby is different and may have different needs.
Consider trying out different brands and sizes to find the best option for your baby’s overnight needs.
Cost Comparison: Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice vs. Target Up & Up’s
If you’re looking to save money on diapers, then opting for store brands like Parent’s Choice and Up & Up is a great way to do it. Both Wal-Mart and Target offer their own brand of diapers that are often the most affordable on the market.
The largest box of Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice diapers costs $0.11 per diaper, while the smallest package costs $0.12 per diaper. On the other hand, Target Up & Up’s cost a bit more at $0.14 per diaper, but the pricing is consistent regardless of the package size. This feature is great because you don’t need the biggest box, and it helps you avoid having a lot of leftover diapers when your kid outgrows a size.
Both diapers are almost half the cost of name-brand diapers, so you will save a lot of money by choosing them. Although Parent’s Choice is slightly cheaper than Up & Up, the difference is almost negligible. Therefore, both brands are great options for parents who want to save money on diapers without sacrificing quality.
To summarize, if you’re looking for affordable diapers, then Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice and Target Up & Up’s are excellent options. Both brands offer great quality at a fraction of the cost of name-brand diapers.
Parent’s Choice does not provide a list of ingredients on their packaging or website. However, Up & Up diapers from Target contain polyester, polypropylene, and polyethylene. These diapers are free of fragrance and latex. In addition, Up & Up diapers are elemental-chlorine free, meaning no direct chlorine is used in the manufacturing process. On the other hand, Wal-Mart diapers do not mention chlorine.
It is worth noting that “elemental chlorine-free” does not necessarily mean that no chlorine is used at all. Other chemicals used in the wood bleaching process may contain chlorine.
In terms of environmental efforts, Parent’s Choice participates in the Sustainable Forestry Initiative, does not conduct animal testing, and has a zero-waste to landfill production facility. Wal-Mart also highlights their sustainability efforts on their packaging.
Overall, Up & Up diapers from Target are the winner in this category due to their transparency in providing an ingredients list and being elemental-chlorine free. However, it is important to note that Parent’s Choice and Wal-Mart also have commendable environmental efforts.
Where are Wal-Mart & Target Diapers Manufactured?
Both Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice diapers and Target Up & Up diapers are manufactured in the USA.
Are Up & Up or Parent’s Choice More Comfortable?
When it comes to the softness of the diapers, Target Up & Up diapers are a little softer than Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice diapers, but the difference is not significant. Both diapers feel fine to a baby in practice.
Parent’s Choice diapers are thinner than Up & Up diapers before encountering liquid. However, both diapers bulk up quite a bit after absorbing. The Target diaper is a little narrower and stouter than the Parent’s Choice diaper when full. The inner filling of the Parent’s Choice diaper felt less secure and would bunch a little more with movement compared to the Target diaper. However, now that the baby is walking, the filling of Target Up & Up diapers bunches up.
Both Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice and Target Up & Up newborn diapers have space for the healing umbilical cord.
Overall, when it comes to comfort, it is a tie between Up & Up and Parent’s Choice diapers. While Up & Up diapers are a bit softer, the filling of both diapers bunch up with movement.
Fit & Secureness: Parents’ Choice & Target Up & Up
When it comes to fit and secureness, both Target Up & Up and Parent’s Choice diapers provide a snug and secure fit. It is important to note that the fit of a diaper can vary depending on the proportions of your baby. For instance, Target Up & Up worked well for a long and lean baby in the 20th percentile and below, but did not fit as well for a different baby.
Both Target Up & Up and Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice diapers have elastic cinching on the back waistband. However, the Wal-Mart diapers have a stretchier waistband and a small pocket in the back waistband, which helps reduce poop blowouts. This pocket is a nice luxury feature to find on a store-brand diaper.
The tabs on both Target Up & Up and Wal-Mart Parent’s Choice diapers feel comparable in terms of stretchiness. Additionally, both diapers stay on well when the baby moves.
However, the ruffle leg material of the Parent’s Choice diaper does not seem as durable compared to the Up & Up’s. It is worth noting that this observation was made when the baby pulled off a part of the material and tried to eat it. While this could be an isolated incident, it is important to keep an eye on the sturdiness of the diapers.
In an update, it was found that Up & Up diapers did not stay on well when the baby started walking, which affected their sturdiness. Therefore, in terms of fit and secureness, Parent’s Choice emerges as the winner due to the added pocket feature at the back of the waistband. It is a premium feature that is nice to see in a store-brand model.
When it comes to the wetness indicator, both Parent’s Choice and Target Up & Up diapers have pH-based wetness indicators. However, Parent’s Choice diapers have an advantage in terms of size indicators. They have clear size indicators that say “Next Size” on the waistband, which eliminates the guesswork of sizing up. In contrast, Target diapers do not have an equivalent size indicator. Both diapers have simple-looking and similar-looking designs, with white shells and simple coloring on the waistbands. However, Up & Up diapers have a second option that has more design on the outer shell. Overall, Parent’s Choice wins this round with their clear size up indicators.
Conclusion: Are Up & Up or Parent’s Choice Diapers Better?
After conducting a thorough comparison of Up & Up and Parent’s Choice diapers, it is clear that Up & Up diapers are the superior choice. While Parent’s Choice diapers may offer a slight cost savings over Up & Up, they do not make up for the gap in performance.
Up & Up diapers outperformed Parent’s Choice diapers in both real-life wear and absorbency tests. In addition, Up & Up diapers offer better overnight protection, comfort, fit, and look. While Parent’s Choice diapers have a back pocket and advertise sustainability efforts, these features are not enough to compensate for the poor absorbency performance.
Furthermore, Up & Up diapers disclose their ingredients, whereas Parent’s Choice diapers do not. Both brands are manufactured in the USA.
In terms of cost, Parent’s Choice diapers are slightly cheaper than Up & Up diapers. However, the superior performance and quality of Up & Up diapers make them worth the extra cost.
If you are still undecided on which brand of diapers to choose, consider checking out some of our other diaper comparisons, including Huggies and Pampers diapers.